When a recipe like the caramel-pear and five-spice upside-down cake comes out right the first time, it’s time to break out a happy dance. There are far too many times, when the tarte tatin and other upside-down cakes sadly need a face lift. You can’t help but feel deflated. A moment of high expectation is turning into one more baking experiment. In the end, there’re always hope for a better outcome next time.
Better outcome, however, is the result of getting things right in the first place. Here is a list I’ve compiled based on my experience in baking this and similar upside-down cakes:
- Equipment and prepping it: I have used a springform pan and it works well. Line the bottom of the pan with a round of parchment paper and smooth it to eliminate air bubbles. Coat the parchment with more oil and set the pan aside.
- However, for a caramel-pear topping, the springform pan is not appropriate because it leaks. The trick is to use a regular non-stick cake pan. Now, get ready for a more complex process when it involves the caramel. Put the empty non-stick pan, on a baking sheet, in the oven. A second trick is: a caramel fruit topping needs a preheated pan to stay at the right working temperature.
- Make the caramel: Making caramel gives me pause; it’s something I don’t get right every time. I understand the part that every cookbook writer tells us: 1) Use real heat, don’t wimp out. 2) Brush down the sugar spattering on the sides of the pan with water, using a pastry brush. 3) Don’t stir, swirl the pan gently to even out the color of the syrup. Lastly, 4) when the color turns amber and you see a few wisps of smoke, remove the pan from heat.
- Off the heat, stand away and squeeze in the juice from a cut lemon in the caramel. The squirt of lemon juice not only flavors the caramel but keeps the sugar from hardening too quickly. This is the best trick I’ve heard!
- Ingredients: In Dorie Greenspan’s recipe, she calls for firm pears which are not very ripe. You also need to cut the pears into 1/2 inch thick. Anything thinner may cause the pieces to stick to the pan. Anything bigger may result in crunchy pears not thoroughly cooked within the 35-38 minutes of baking. There is always the delicate balance between texture, baking time and the structure of the cake. The good news is we’ve found the sweet spot here!
- A word on the cake batter. Like most upside-down cakes, this is a sponge cake built on the rough ratios of 1 part egg: 1 part sugar: 1 part flour: 1 part fat, leavened by baking powder. Rather than butter, the batter uses neutral oil, such as canola. Furthermore, the batter is flavored with lemon, ginger and Chinese five-spice powder — the essence of warmth and welcome. Believe it or not, all the ingredients go in and come together quickly in a food processor within seconds.
- Rest and Unmold: Bake until the top is browned, about 35 minutes. The cake should pull away slightly from edges of pan; a tester inserted into the center should come out clean. Let’s the cake cool for 5-10 minutes before inverting onto the cake plate. Sugared fruit will stick to the pan if left to cool for too long.
Without pulling a lot of stops, but by carefully following the guidelines above step by step, we can all feel like the star bakers. The caramel-pear and five-spice upside-down cake looks all decorated and ready for primetime. For sure, this bake restores my confidence that I, too, can make one of these cakes.
5 Comments
Diane Zwang
October 29, 2022 at 1:32 pmYou got great caramelization on this one. It looks beautiful. This was a lovely dessert.
Mardi (eat. live. travel. write.)
October 29, 2022 at 2:17 pmBeautiful cake!
steph (whisk/spoon)
October 31, 2022 at 10:32 amgorgeous– love seeing the line of caramel on the side of the cake. I really enjoyed this one and the food processor trick was great.
Kim
November 1, 2022 at 6:03 pmOhhh you got the deep mahogany color! Good job!!
Rosa Jackson's Bourride | Last Recipe from Everyday Dorie - Ever Open Sauce
February 23, 2024 at 5:09 pm[…] details are too small or insignificant for Dorie. That reminds me of the caramel-pear and five-spice upside down cake (pate 238). If you’re a novice or a nervous carameler, take note. The best trick to keep the […]